Baby D's Bagels
$20 Worth of Food and Drink for Only $10

July 30, 2013

For whom the bridge tolls

The Ohio River Bridges Project unveils a pricing proposal, and (surprise!) some people aren’t happy

Avery Koler brought white poster board with the handwritten quip, “This sign is more transparent than the Ohio River Bridges Project.” He planned to hold the visual aide up during the second of two public meetings held by the ORBP to discuss proposed tolls and their potential impact on low-income and minority communities. Koler, a Louisville Climate Action Network board member who characterizes the proposed tolls as immoral, was ready to show his support during community leaders’ and concerned citizens’ impassioned pleas for income-based toll considerations.

Instead, Koler found the public forum wasn’t a standard town hall meeting where a protest sign would fit in but an open house, with a looped five-minute video explaining the project and a dozen project officials milling about maps and renderings, answering individual questions. Comments were taken via paper forms and orally via onsite court reporters. Though a press conference was held so local legislators could publicly voice outcry over what they call a regressive tax on the poor, the official meeting was woefully understated, considering how opinionated people are when it comes to transportation issues, especially bridges.

Koler was one of many disappointed at the format and worried that outrage and suggestions regarding tolls and the bridges will fall on deaf ears. “This feels like an attempt to build the impression of inevitability, when it is not inevitable,” he says.

Project officials unsurprisingly feel otherwise, saying they are willing and open to the 150 online comments submitted through and the 250 submitted in person during the two open-house meetings held this month.

The ORBP is one of the country’s largest transportation efforts — and it’s costly. Since the public conversation on tolls began years ago, fervor has centered on not tolling existing bridges that are already paid for. Proposed now is a plan that would toll three of Kentuckiana’s five eventual bridges: a new East End Bridge, which will connect Prospect, Ky., and Utica, Ind., and the I-65 bridges, which will consist of a revamped Kennedy Bridge for southbound traffic and a new Downtown Bridge for northbound traffic.

The Clark Memorial Bridge, better known as the Second Street Bridge, and the Sherman Minton Bridge, which connects west Louisville with New Albany, will remain free.

Proposed tolls include $1 per crossing for “frequent commuters,” a term that hasn’t been defined; $2 per crossing for commuters not classified as frequent; $5 per crossing for panel or box trucks; and $10 per crossing for semi-trucks or tractor trailer rigs. Additional fees or higher tolls would be tacked on for commuters not paying via a wireless transponder system, which automatically deducts funds from a prepaid account whenever it crosses a bridge. (Those without transponders would have a photo of their vehicle taken as they crossed the bridge and be held accountable for fees later. No physical tollbooths will be installed.)


That undefined standard of “frequent” is a pressing concern for many, says Kentucky Transportation Cabinet spokesman Chuck Wolfe. Numerous residents have raised concerns about how people with atypical schedules will be affected.

“What constitutes a frequent commuter? Not everyone works 8 to 5 Monday through Friday. Some work 12 hours on, 12 off. Some do four 10-hour shifts,” says Wolfe. “Those people are concerned. If the threshold were 40 crossings per month, would they qualify? It’s a valid concern.”

It’s a concern student Misty Trunnell addressed as one of several speakers at the press conference held outside the ORBP’s Kentucky open house. The Louisville resident typically tries to schedule her classes at Ivy Tech Community College in Sellersburg, Ind., on the same weekdays to cut down on gas costs and drive time but wonders if doing so would mean paying a higher toll rate. She calculated her current transportation costs to be 9 percent of her income and says tolls would almost double it to 17 percent. Doable, but barely, on her meager income, which comes from being an assistant to a disabled woman, as well as whatever odd jobs she can fit in between school and being a mother.

“When you’re on a limited income, you know where every dollar is,” Trunnell says. “I’d have to reconfigure everything.”

Officials note that, compared to other tolled bridges past and present, the ORBP proposed tolls are reasonable. The Second Street Bridge opened in 1929 with a 35-cent toll, which is $4.64 in today’s dollars.

Still, even at the lowest rate of $1 per crossing, a commuter could pay upwards of $500 annually in tolls. For a minimum-wage earner, that’s equivalent to 70 hours of work. The comparison was made by nine Kentucky legislators in an open letter to Gov. Steve Beshear, asking him to support House Bill 129, which would give an annual reimbursement of up to $500 a year in toll-related work costs to anyone eligible for the federal Earned Income Tax Credit.

HB 129 would also exempt TARC buses from tolls. TARC buses cross the bridges 946 times per week during their fixed routes. Additionally, TARC3, the paratransit service available for people with disabilities, crosses the bridge 140 times every weekday. Making these vehicles pay $10 per crossing would strain an already stretched public transportation system and could result in higher fares for riders, which would disproportionately affect low-income and minority communities.

A 2009 TARC survey found 47 percent of riders had an annual household income of less than $20,000 and 24 percent were between $20,000 and $39,999. The same survey found that 59 percent of riders were African-American. Although comparable survey data from 2013 has yet to be analyzed, TARC Marketing Director Kay Stewart says nothing indicates significant change in those ridership statistics.

Stewart says she is “cautiously optimistic” TARC will be exempt from tolls. Earlier this month, the board of directors overseeing TARC approved a resolution seeking exemption from the bridge tolls.

The states have dedicated $20 million toward improving TARC routes and awareness. It’s one of many components meant to lesson the impact on the low-income community. Others include offering low-cost transponders, allowing low minimum balances on transponder accounts, and making replenishing those accounts easy and accessible.

A six-person bi-state committee will ultimately make decisions on tolls, which are supposed to go into effect in 2016. That means, open houses aside, there’s still time.

“I don’t think it’s fair or reasonable to instill tolls on the working poor,” said Sen. Gerald Neal (D) at the press conference against tolls for the low-income community. “I’m calling on state officials to not write in stone these tolls. Take this issue seriously.” 

bridge tolls

By JimLahey
“I don’t think it’s fair or reasonable to instill tolls on the working poor,” said Sen. Gerald Neal...
Surely he said "impose", right? Who is transcribing these things? I hope he didn't say "instill".

While tolls may cause disparate negative impacts for the poor, are we also adding up positive impacts for the poor? What if easily-passable bridges extend the radius of job prospects for everyone? I would gladly pay $2/day in exchange for safe and efficient travel to a better job than the one I have now. And even if my job doesn't involve crossing the river, reduced congestion on the interstates might make it easier to get to my job wherever it is.

The proposed fee structure for varying trip quantities doesn't make much sense. This structure creates a "donut hole" in which it would be cheaper to take more trips in order to surpass the price break. A more sensible policy would charge $2 for the first X trips per month, then a discounted rate for all trips above that number. First 10 trips within a month are $2, after that $1, no one gets special treatment.

Does anyone have any good info on the fiscal status of TARC? I'm new here and don't know what the deal is. Adding a reasonable infrastructure toll should come out as a wash for what is essentially another part of infrastructure (a municipal bus service). While the toll might add to the costs side of the balance sheet, the added efficiency of travel combined with the expected increase in ridership should cancel out the additional nominal costs. If TARC cannot afford $10 per crossing, then TARC has bigger problems than the proposed toll.

Great post I would like to

By johnmak1122
Great post I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this interesting and knowledgeable article. what does bubblegum casting do

This is a excellent site,

By jazonewil
This is a excellent site, would you be interested in doing an interview regarding how you developed it? If so e-mail me! horney wife, looking for an affair pennsylvania extramarital affair personals, getting laid wife rhode island watching my wife getting laid, hot wife allie arizona hot pictures of my wife flirt dating single love 2008 maine online

I am happy to find this post

By ronan1122
I am happy to find this post Very useful for me, as it contains lot of information. I Always prefer to read The Quality and glad I found this thing in you post. Thanks bubblegum casting

Interesting topic for a

By ronan1122
Interesting topic for a blog. I have been searching the Internet for fun and came upon your website. Fabulous post. Thanks a ton for sharing your knowledge! It is great to see that some people still put in an effort into managing their websites. I'll be sure to check back again real soon. bubblegum casting


By luoyu
It also isnt about the way the watch looks. I have an expensive watch that was given to me as a gift. It was a hand-me-down from someone who can afford the luxury of an expensive watch, actually, since I gained possession of this when they bought used fancier version. Im not known for my lavish income Im guessing that people have no idea that its expensive. To that point, the Rolex serves to reinforce a persons brand, not generate it. A poor man wearing a looks like a poor man with a. However, for the right man, the Rolex Oyster will serve to reinforce the idea that they is doing well indeed.

Nice to be visiting your

By ronan1122
Nice to be visiting your blog once more, it continues to be months for me. Nicely this post that i’ve been waited for so lengthy. capture his heart and make him love you forever

You make so many great

By ronan1122
You make so many great points here that I read your article a couple of times. Your views are in accordance with my own for the most part. This is great content for your readers.

Thanks for sharing this great article

By arcarro
carbono do que os de origem veículo e sua condição operacional. Os ar condicionado de origem luvas é aconselhável quando existir o acionamento ou desligamento parafínica. ar condicionado de maior manutenção obtidos de um mesmo tipo do ar condicionado veiculo de manutenção automotivo, deixam maior de resíduos que os de menor manutenção. Também, ar condicionado refinados uso de luvas é aconselhável quando existir o acionamento ou desligamento das mangueiras.

I real delighted to find

By ronan1122
I real delighted to find this site on bing, just what I was looking for : D also bookmarked Dale Buczkowski

Outstanding post, you have

By ronan1122
Outstanding post, you have pointed out some good details , I likewise conceive this s a very good website. hebergeur minecraft

This is really a nice and

By ronan1122
This is really a nice and informative, containing all information and also has a great impact on the new technology. Thanks for sharing it

hello, your website is

By ronan1122
hello, your website is really good. We do appreciate your give good results Visit Comalgerie

The news that the Second

By dazzlema
The news that the Second Street Bridge and Sherman Minton Bridge will remain free was nice to hear, I travel often between West Louisville and New Albany with my jeep from jeep Dealer Westchester. I am not against paying a small fee because I know these money will be invested in useful projects, the problem is that the authorities did not think to create a kind of ticket system for people that have to cross the bridge twice a day.

Think about everything from

By comment
Think about everything from your underground room, and the cellars of everyone you know, congealed into six huge spheres is bubblegum casting legitimate


By soccerkent
“I don’t think it’s fair or reasonable to instill tolls on the working poor,” said Sen. Gerald Neal (D) at the press conference against tolls for the low-income community. “I’m calling on state officials to not write in stone these tolls. Take this issue seriously.” I very much agree with this jersey:wholesale soccer jerseys