Photo by Joe Sonka

May 30, 2012

Fail Safe

Dismas Charities puts violent offenders to work at the zoo, raising questions about safety

As a volunteer in the Dismas Charities inmate work release program, Todd Duke spent his days cleaning animal cages and performing janitorial duties for the Kentucky Humane Society.

Shortly after arriving for work on the morning of April 30, Louisville Metro Police say Duke shoved a female Humane Society employee into a room and locked the door.

Once inside the locked room, Duke allegedly exposed his genitals, forcibly kissed the woman, pulled her hair in an attempt to force her into oral sex, and tried to pull her pants off. The victim was left with bruises all over her body, but managed to get free and run to safety.

Duke was arrested and charged with attempted rape and attempted sodomy.

The Kentucky Humane Society immediately terminated participation in the Dismas worker program, saying in a statement that “protecting (our) employees and volunteers is our number one priority.”

Dismas Charities is contracted by the Kentucky Department of Corrections to run halfway houses that allow prisoners to volunteer at organizations throughout the state for 63 cents a day and time off their sentence. The majority of the work is performed in Louisville at various city agencies and nonprofit organizations.

In recent years, Dismas has faced increasing public scrutiny, in large part due to a scathing state audit that revealed exorbitant expenses and executive salaries, as well as a lack of oversight. There’s also been more sordid publicity, including tales of sexual trysts, drug use and theft by Dismas workers while on the job at Louisville Metro Animal Services, and a murder at its halfway house in Old Louisville in 2008.

Duke — serving time for a meth manufacturing conviction — had volunteered without incident at the Humane Society since February, when he was transferred from a brief assignment at the Louisville Zoo, where he worked in the horticultural department. The zoo is one of several city agencies that uses the free labor of Dismas, along with Metro Animal Services, Metro Parks, Metro Police, Public Health and Wellness, and the Solid Waste Division.

And though Metro Government’s stated policy agreement with Dismas prohibits anyone with a violent criminal history from working for the city, Duke’s long rap sheet includes violent crimes, with previous convictions for assault and resisting arrest.

Both Louisville Zoo officials and a spokesman for Mayor Greg Fischer say they were unaware that Dismas allowed a volunteer with such a criminal history to work at the zoo.

But as it turns out, Duke isn’t the only Dismas worker with a violent criminal past, according to records obtained by LEO Weekly.

In recent years, the Louisville Zoo has used several Dismas workers with a history of violent crime. And despite the zoo’s additional requirement excluding workers convicted of drug trafficking, several Dismas workers have had such a conviction, including two that currently work there.

The presence of such workers at the Louisville Zoo — unbeknownst to zoo management — is compounded by the fact that there are questions as to whether the Dismas crews are being properly watched while on the job site.

Zoo employees in charge of supervising former inmates participate in annual 30-minute training sessions on how to do so. But despite a city policy requiring close monitoring at all times, zoo officials acknowledge Dismas workers in the horticultural department are often well out of the line of sight of supervisors (a fact LEO Weekly confirmed during a recent visit to the zoo).

Given the fact that just a cursory review of limited records reveals numerous violent offenders have landed at the zoo through the Dismas program, it’s likely there have been more at other city agencies, as well. It’s a revelation that raises serious questions about the safety of both paid employees and the public.

Jerry A. Moneymaker was convicted on three counts of first-degree assault and one count of first-degree burglary in 1984 and sentenced to 60 years. Through the state’s early release program, Moneymaker was allowed to serve out the remainder of a reduced sentence with Dismas Charities, which placed him at the Louisville Zoo for eight months in 2009.

When asked how Moneymaker — someone with an indisputably violent criminal history — was approved for such work, neither the zoo nor the Mayor’s Office had an answer, both claiming to be unaware of the situation.

For Metro Government — as well as state government, which has overcrowded prisons — the Dismas work-release program has been a welcome presence for decades. In theory, it’s a win-win: Felons are able to transition back into free society, while still being under strict supervision, as they help city agencies perform manual labor tasks at no cost.

But agencies like the zoo — as well as the city’s Human Resources Department — do not conduct additional background checks on workers sent from Dismas, as they assume Dismas only accepts nonviolent offenders.

“(Dismas’) stated policy is that the program itself does not accept workers with a violent criminal background,” says mayoral spokesman Phil Miller. “So we expect them to follow that policy, and that was an important policy for us, in terms of allowing this to go forward.”

An inventory of Dismas workers who volunteered at the zoo (obtained by open records request) reveals that in the last two years the zoo has employed at least four workers convicted of first-degree burglary — that’s in addition to Duke and Moneymaker, both with violent criminal pasts. Burglary is deemed first-degree in Kentucky when the violator uses or threatens to use a deadly weapon, or assaults an inhabitant during the crime. Another zoo worker was sentenced to 10 years for arson.

LEO also obtained a copy of the Louisville Zoo’s worker requirements, which prohibits the use of inmates with a drug trafficking conviction. Despite the rule, the zoo has used at least five Dismas workers with such a conviction over the last two years, including two that currently work there, according to records.

Though LEO obtained a worker inventory from the zoo, the records do not explain why most Dismas volunteers stopped working there. Louisville Zoo spokeswoman Kyle Shepherd says Dismas Charities — not the zoo — possesses any records of complaints or disciplinary actions for the workers.

A spokesman for Dismas Charities initially told LEO that if the Kentucky Department of Corrections deems prisoners worthy of entering their halfway houses, they have no problem sending them to city agencies to volunteer.

“If they’re qualified for ‘community custody’ and they meet all the requirements that we set down, yeah, they go,” said Bob Yates, vice president of public relations for Dismas.

In a follow-up call from LEO seeking disciplinary records for workers, as well as clarification on the difference of opinion with the city on worker eligibility, Yates refused comment. Specifically, Yates said he would not make any comment because of this publication’s past coverage of Dismas, calling LEO a “piece of crap.”

Refusal to answer questions and provide information is nothing new for Dismas Charities: In a scathing review of Dismas in 2010, state Auditor Crit Luallen cited the organization’s failure to cooperate and provide sufficient records for her investigation.

Todd Henson, public information director at the Kentucky Department of Correction’s Contract Management Branch, says Dismas is contractually obligated to accept any prisoner into their halfway house whom the department classifies as “community custody,” thus deemed as not posing a great risk to the public if supervised properly.

But this definition of “community custody” is perhaps where the communication breakdown lies between Dismas and the city.

Though the zoo’s spokeswoman tells LEO that inmates classified as “community custody” are welcome to volunteer, Henson notes that the Department of Corrections sometimes classifies violent offenders and drug traffickers into this category near the end of their sentences, as was presumably the case with Duke, Moneymaker and others.

But while Dismas is obligated to take such inmates into their halfway houses, Henson says city agencies are under no such obligation to use them and can set up any parameters or requirements that they wish.

Despite the fact that Dismas worker Todd Duke stands accused of attempted rape — along with the revelation that other Dismas workers have violent histories — neither the Mayor’s Office nor the Louisville Zoo plans to cut ties with the organization.

“Even though we’re concerned over these two instances (Duke and Moneymaker), the big picture is that it has been a remarkably incident-free and trouble-free program, as far as city government is concerned,” Miller says.

In 2010, however, Dismas garnered much media attention — including a story in LEO — due to multiple instances of inmates engaging in drug use, sexual intercourse and misappropriation of city property while working at Metro Animal Services.

The negative publicity did not deter the city from continuing to work with Dismas.

That said, the lure of free labor in times of budgetary restraint cannot be overlooked.

“They’re not paid and are doing this as part of their community service commitment,” Miller says. “And they really provide a lot of good services that in some cases we might otherwise have to pay for.”

According to Dismas, their workers performed 360,000 hours of work throughout Kentucky (approximately 309,000 done in Louisville) last year. When computed at the minimum wage rate, that resulted in a savings of roughly $2.5 million for those organizations.

However cheap Dismas labor is, Wesley Stover — the president of AFSCME Local 2629, which represents more than 100 workers at the Louisville Zoo — warns that it doesn’t come without a price.

Stover says that free Dismas labor at the zoo is cutting into potential hours and positions for employees, which violates city policy. But he also argues that the program — especially in light of the Duke incident — jeopardizes the safety of workers and the public.

“We’ve had our members come to us and voice concerns about Dismas inmate workers being rude, being argumentative, stepping into their personal space,” Stover says. “They want our AFSCME members to watch over and give direction to these inmates, and obviously they’re not properly trained for that.

“They’re concerned for their safety, and they have reason to be concerned.”

Stover also notes that Dismas workers — who wear uniforms and photo ID badges like city employees — are indistinguishable from regular staff at the zoo.

“They’re not wearing an orange jumpsuit that says ‘inmate.’ It doesn’t say ‘convicted felon,’” Stover says. “So John Smith’s family is out there walking their kids around, and what you think is just another worker is a convicted criminal.”

There’s also the troubling fact that signs posted throughout the zoo instruct lost children to “go to any uniformed zoo employee” if separated.

And despite city policy indicating Dismas workers must be supervised at all times, this is not always the case.

Dismas participants take TARC into work on their own, allowing them brief access to the parking lot before and after work, and they are unmonitored for short periods when they get lunch. Stover says several employees have told him that Dismas workers have been dismissed for breaking into cars and theft, but without records provided by the zoo or Dismas, this could not be verified.

Horticultural workers are especially capable of eluding supervisors while on the job, as they cut the lawns that wind around the 135-acre zoo. However, zoo spokeswoman Kyle Shepherd says that when they mow the lawn, “We know where they are and check in on them periodically.”

Last week, LEO observed a Dismas worker cutting grass for nearly an hour at the far corner of the zoo, next to the non-fenced backyard of a subdivision and a parking lot with school buses full of children. There was no other zoo employee in the area.

Despite these concerns, the Mayor’s Office says the recent revelations should not overshadow the many Dismas volunteers who have done their job properly throughout the years without incident.

“Two apparent violations of their own policy over three or four years in the hundreds of volunteers that we’ve gotten doesn’t appear to be a huge trend of violating their own policy,” spokesman Phil Miller says. “But we’ll certainly be looking into that and reinforcing that this is the stated policy and we expect them to live up to it.”

The Mayor’s Office has not been in contact with Dismas Charities since the arrest of Todd Duke at the Kentucky Human Society, which is not a city agency.

“The Dismas program is overseen by our HR department, not by the Mayor’s Office,” Miller says. “But nevertheless, we’ve not had a specific conversation with them, to my knowledge, about the policy since the Duke situation.”

Asked if the zoo was concerned about being sent criminals with a violent record by Dismas, Louisville Zoo spokeswoman Shepherd initially told LEO that the zoo has “had a successful partnership with Dismas since 1989 based on the management and selection of the volunteers by Dismas,” adding, “Our agreement with Dismas is that we do not accept violent offenders.”

A week later, Louisville Zoo Director John Walczak followed up with a much stronger statement.

“We are extremely disappointed with Dismas for not following our agreed upon policy for volunteer selection and will require Dismas to tighten up its practices to ensure this will not happen again,” Walczak explained via email.

Walczak re-emphasized that the zoo has no disciplinary records of Dismas workers, but added, “We haven’t had any notable incidents with Dismas volunteers.”

As for the zoo’s supervision of Dismas workers, Walczak says that they will now re-examine the supervisor training, which he says is conducted by the Kentucky Department of Corrections. “The zoo has initiated a review to determine if the extent of this training meets our high standards for ensuring a safe environment for our guests.” 

Unfortunate

By caligirl845
What is your beef with Dismas? What is the reason for your dislike of ex-offenders? Was it really necessary to print names of residents that were at one time in a Dismas program and their criminal record? Did you ever go as far to research the ex residents to find out what is going on with them now? How sad that people can do their time, become successful in their lives and then have someone publish their past wrong doings for the sake of proving a point. How do you think Mr. Moneymaker feels, and how his family feels? He has been placed in the middle of something that has nothing to really do with him. Shame on you for trashing these people -when exactly has a person done enough to repay their "debt to society"? Thank goodness for people like Dismas who can see something in people other than their pasts, and who are willing to give a person a second chance. Mr. Sanka, I would say that you don't believe in second chances; hope you never make a mistake and need forgiveness.

Call girl

By bastardo
Do you consider Todd Duke an "ex-offender". Or do his new offenses make him a "re-offender"? Did Dismas fail to properly rehabilitate him? Did Dismas miss what must have been obvious signs of aggression and hostility towards women? Why did you, as an employee of Dismas, allow this to happen? That young woman has been traumatized for life. I don't detect any amount of concern for her or the thousands of other victims of your ex-offenders' crimes. El Bastardo

The Kentucky Humane Society

By passionlab
The Kentucky Humane Society immediately terminated participation in the Dismas worker program, saying in a statement that “protecting (our) employees and volunteers is our number one priority.” home page

To make it easy for yacht

By imssol
To make it easy for yacht charter enthusiasts, the local authorities have set up a small train which actually makes a tour within the town of yacht charter Kos, passing by all major sightseeing spots http://www.yachtcharterkos.com/

Interesting post. I Have

By ronan1122
Interesting post. I Have Been wondering about this issue, so thanks for posting. Pretty cool post.It 's really very nice and Useful post.Thanks capture his heart and make him love you forever

I recently found many useful

By leesa
I recently found many useful information in your website especially this blog page. Among the lots of comments on your articles. Thanks for sharing. Roti making machine

Thanks for posting this

By carter1122
Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can't wait to read lots of your posts. http://textmate2.org/

I was checking constantly

By sarazara2
I was checking constantly this blog and I’m impressed! Extremely useful info specially the last part I care for such information a lot. I was seeking this certain info for a long time. Thank you and good luck. Get More Information

Great job for publishing

By carter1122
Great job for publishing such a beneficial web site. Your web log isn’t only useful but it is additionally really creative too. There tend to be not many people who can certainly write not so simple posts that artistically. Continue the nice writing how can i reconcile with my ex

This tray is awesome!! I've

By leesa
This tray is awesome!! I've been using the Bumbo seat for about 9 months now but I just recently bought the tray. Bio products

The flip video camera

By sarazara2
The flip video camera contest is really so competitive and interesting. That was a nice video to watch. So cool. Those who needs to know about optimizing techniques can go for the Toronto seo company. baby hazel games

The victim was left with

By sarazara2
The victim was left with bruises all over her body, but managed to get free and run to safety. weed grinder

Your blog provided us with

By leesa
Your blog provided us with valuable information to work with. Each & every tips of your post are awesome. Thanks a lot for sharing. Keep blogging, Casting Engineering Works in Hyderabad

I have recently started a

By leesa
I have recently started a blog, the info you provide on this site has helped me greatly. Thanks for all of your time & work. chick feeder

The zoo is one of several

By sarazara2
The zoo is one of several city agencies that uses the free labor of Dismas, along with Metro Animal Services, Metro Parks, Metro Police, Public Health and Wellness, and the Solid Waste Division. crazy mass

Very nice article, I enjoyed

By carter1122
Very nice article, I enjoyed reading your post, very nice share, I want to twit this to my followers. Thanks!. Royal Vegas Casino

Great post I would like to

By ronan1122
Great post I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this interesting and knowledgeable article. exercise bikes

Thanks for discussing the

By sarazara2
Thanks for discussing the post.. mother and father are planets best individual in each lifestyles of personal. https://www.rebelmouse.com/metaldetectorsonline

I was looking for some

By hw3ffkc
I was looking for some topics that are enough popular and finally founded your blog, it has superb topics with great popularity yachtbooker

That is actually good blog.

By sarazara2
That is actually good blog. I have a bunch myself. therefore i admire your design. I do know this is off subject however,did you make this design yourself purchase from somewhere. venus factor

This is a great inspiring

By ashleydanielle
This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information. Keep it up. Keep blogging. Looking to reading your next post. www.assistantplusonlinesolutions.com

Thanks for the blog loaded

By carter1122
Thanks for the blog loaded with so many information. Stopping by your blog helped me to get what I was looking for. https://rebelmouse.com/truthfatburningfoodsreview/

And although religious

By sarazara2
And although religious groups staunchly disagree, there has not been a major push urging the groups to take down the signs. Homes Bought Fast

I would like to thank you

By sarazara2
I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this interesting and knowledgeable article. click at this site

I think this is a really

By ronan1122
I think this is a really good article. You make this information interesting and engaging. You give readers a lot to think about and I appreciate that kind of writing. glazen schuifdeuren

I was looking at some of

By jimy5500
I was looking at some of your posts on this website and I conceive this web site is really instructive! Keep putting up.. vitamin c serum 20

This is such a great

By carter1122
This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. get her interested

The information you have

By ashleydanielle
The information you have posted is very useful. The sites you have referred was good. Thanks for sharing... desire system review

Harm of dental developments

By alone17
Harm of dental developments usually happens which are certain disadvantages as well as the occurrence of strikes within the mouth Oral travel and leisure. www.chandlersca.co.uk

Not only do we keep

By sarazara2
Not only do we keep gathering, but we think we are entitled to, or have gained what we have. “The mind-set of right saps us of our capability to provide thanks, to get the products of lifestyle as presents,” creates Bader-Saye. http://fbgamecheats.org

Great info! I recently came

By robert1122
Great info! I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don’t know what to say except that I have. woolrich

If you set out to make me

By ronan1122
If you set out to make me think today; mission accomplished! I really like your writing style and how you express your ideas. Thank you. The Blue Fish Inn Articles

I can see that you are an

By ronan1122
I can see that you are an expert at your field! I am launching a website soon, and your information will be very useful for me.. Thanks for all your help and wishing you all the success in your business. gfas

I wanted to thank you for

By ashleydanielle
I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post. female mind mastery kirsten price reviews

Positive site, where did u

By ashleydanielle
Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting?I have read a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style. Thanks a million and please keep up the effective work. pokies

Thanks for posting this

By ronan1122
Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can't wait to read lots of your posts. bubblegum casting

Wow i can say that this is

By davidalan1122
Wow i can say that this is another great article as expected of this blog.Bookmarked this site.. buy pre written research papers

Shortly after arriving for

By passionlab
Shortly after arriving for work on the morning of April 30, Louisville Metro Police say Duke shoved a female Humane Society employee into a room and locked the door personal finance management

I think this is an

By robert1122
I think this is an informative post and it is very useful and knowledgeable. therefore, I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. best tanning lotion

Thank you very much for

By ronan1122
Thank you very much for writing such an interesting article on this topic. This has really made me think and I hope to read more. télécharger minecraft

Your website is really cool

By johnmak1122
Your website is really cool and this is a great inspiring article. what does bubblegum casting do

Interesting post. I Have

By ashleydanielle
Interesting post. I Have Been wondering about this issue, so thanks for posting. Pretty cool post.It 's really very nice and Useful post.Thanks www.rebelmouse.com/kyleleonmusclemaximizer/

I am sure about this album

By jams123
I am sure about this album that it is really deserved to be bought and listen again and again. I first time hear it on my Philippines tour when I have in my bubblegum casting

I think that thanks for the

By ashleydanielle
I think that thanks for the valuabe information and insights you have so provided here. How to get fake likes on Facebook

I wanted to thank you for

By ashleydanielle
I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post. http://ge.tt/9xpUUxP1/v/0

This is a great inspiring

By carter1122
This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information. Keep it up. Keep blogging. Looking to reading your next post. yeast infection no more pdf

It is imperative that we

By ashleydanielle
It is imperative that we read blog post very carefully. I am already done it and find that this post is really amazing. buy instagram likes

I have bookmarked your blog,

By stuartlittle1122
I have bookmarked your blog, the articles are way better than other similar blogs.. thanks for a great blog! media buying

I am happy to find this

By nouva
I am happy to find this website because the information contained in this web is very helpful for visitors, Crystal X NASA especially for my own, we wait for the next article update which is certainly more likely to provide information that is more interesting. I also have some good information here Ciri-ciri Crystal X Asli

Second Chances

By skelley (not verified)
This story does not suggest criminal offender re-entry programs are bad or that people do not deserve second chances. This is about an organization that seems to have lost sight of that mission, both through dysfunction internally and lack of proper oversight externally. In fact, I would argue that Dismas' transgressions only make the public more resistant to second chances.