Baby D's Bagels
$20 Worth of Food and Drink for Only $10
Photo courtesy of Kentucky Heritage Counsel

June 9, 2010

The $260 million home

East End property inflates Ohio River Bridges Project price tag

If you want an idea of how expensive the $4.1 billion Ohio River Bridges Project really is, consider the Drumanard.

Built in 1929 by wealthy landowners Alexander Watson and his wife, Jessie Strater, the Drumanard — that’s Scottish for “hill top” — is located at 6401 Wolf Pen Branch Road, secluded by a winding trail lined with trees planted by the firm of Olmstead Associates. There’s a majestic garden, a gazebo and even a gardener’s house sharing the 49 acres of pristine East End real estate.

Bucolic though it may be, the Strater-Watsons, described by the Filson Historical Society as “an affluent, socially active Louisville family,” would likely have never envisioned that their country estate would today be gumming up the works for the most expensive infrastructure project in Kentucky history.

Because Drumanard is listed on the National Register of Historic Places, and lies directly in the path of an on-ramp to the proposed East End bridge, traffic engineers are required by the 1966 Historic Preservation Act to build that on-ramp underneath the property — to the tune of $260 million, and rising.

Since the tab for an East End bridge approach clocks in at $753 million, a Drumanard tunnel will consume up to 33 percent of the cost.

“Obviously, the costs associated with it are the biggest issue,” says J.C. Stites, co-founder of 8664, an alternative proposal to the ORBP that includes the construction of an East End bridge as a core component. ORBP, on the other hand, proposes construction of a downtown and an East End bridge. When asked about Drumanard’s historic designation, Stites says, “I think it’s fair to question the motives for it being put on the historic registry.”

Like many proponents of a scaled-down solution to the unwieldy public works project, Stites believes Drumanard is unfairly halting bridge construction in the East End at the expense of other historic properties downtown, namely the Butchertown neighborhood, which under the ORBP plan would lose several blocks to the expansion of Spaghetti Junction, including the Louisville Extreme Park.

“One of the great scholars of the historic preservation movement is Donovan Rypkema,” Stites says of the Washington, D.C.-based real estate planner. “He gave a speech a few years ago (at a 2006 smart growth conference), saying that historic preservation has changed. ‘The dead rich white guy approach is over, we’ve moved beyond that.’ The idea of saving these big mansions and preserving them while we’re losing the fabric of our historic neighborhoods is not a fair trade off.”

Mark Dennen, executive director of the Kentucky Heritage Council, believes that since Drumanard’s application was approved, then a legitimate case was made for its historical significance.

“We feel a pretty strong case was made by the application for that listing,” Dennen says. “Otherwise, it wouldn’t be listed. From a preservation standpoint, if something has gone through the process, and met all the criteria, then there was definitely a case to be made that was ultimately accepted.”

Plus, he says determining historical significance is a subjective endeavor, and that one property’s value can’t be judged against another’s. In this context, consider also the Farmington estate, which was home to the Speed family and, for a few weeks, Abraham Lincoln. Built in the early 1800s, it also happens to be located closer to I-264 than Drumanard would be to the East End ramp, whose aboveground construction would only devastate a few acres of trees.

When asked about this, Dennen concludes, “We don’t look at properties in comparison to other properties.”

Marianne Zickuhr, executive director of Preservation Louisville, agrees — for the most part.

“I think everyone’s going to have a different opinion,” she says. “In the end, no matter which direction this project takes, we should always talk about the possibility of preserving what we have. We’re not going to come out in favor of either bridge. Both would have an impact on historic structures in a very negative fashion.”

This all-encompassing preservationist ethos jibes with that of River Fields, a wealthy conservation group that has lobbied consistently for the construction of a downtown bridge to preserve its holdings in the East End.

“I can’t really speak to the governance of River Fields,” Zickuhr says. “River Fields encompasses more than just preservation. They aren’t the same organization as we are. I just want to be very clear that Preservation Louisville isn’t going to be in support of the destruction of any asset across the city. We’ll do that whether it’s in the East End, Butchertown, Germantown or Portland.”

Lee Cochran, former director of River Fields, says she left the organization for this very reason.

“It got to a point where it wasn’t about preservation anymore,” she says. “The Drumanard is obviously not your average story of ‘Joe gets a job, Joe buys a house, Joe raises a family.’ It’s about preserving the history of the rich at the expense of the poor.”

In 1988, the Jefferson County Office of Historic Preservation and Archives submitted an application to the National Register of Historic Places in an effort to get a historic designation for Drumanard. At the time, then-property owner Mary Peabody Fitzhugh submitted a letter objecting to her home’s listing on the registry, although without giving a reason. Four years later, however, she rescinded the objection, and the designation was approved. LEO Weekly placed calls to members of the Fitzhugh family, but did not receive a response.

A 2007 Courier-Journal article quotes a Harrods Creek fire chief who believes the tunnels would be more dangerous for vehicles than the Cumberland Gap tunnel, which is the longest underground tunnel in the state. And in just three years alone, the cost of the tunnel has skyrocketed 300 percent.

Meanwhile, the Louisville-Southern Indiana bridges Authority is scrambling to find a way to pay for the Drumanard tunnels as well as the rest of the project. By the end of the month, they expect to have a working financial plan, which will inevitably include some form of tolls, whose ultimate price is directly affected by the ballooning costs. 

Preservation Louisville / River Fields connection

By Stevietheman
It should be noted that Bob Griffith, the President of Preservation Louisville serves as the Legal Counsel for River Fields. Steve Magruder - Louisville History & Issues - www.historyandissues.org

You’ve got some

By ronan1122
You’ve got some interesting points in this article. I would have never considered any of these if I didn’t come across this. Thanks!. chaussures de sécurité

Thanks for taking the time

By ronan1122
Thanks for taking the time to discuss that, I feel strongly about this and so really like getting to know more on this kind of field. Do you mind updating your blog post with additional insight? It should be really useful for all of us. compte minecraft gratuit

I was looking at some of

By ronan1122
I was looking at some of your posts on this website and I conceive this web site is really instructive! Keep putting up.. bubblegum casting

Thank you for some other

By ronan1122
Thank you for some other informative website. The place else may just I get that kind of information written in such a perfect method? I have a venture that I am simply now running on, and I’ve been at the glance out for such info. bubblegum casting

Excellent .. Amazing ..

By ronan1122
Excellent .. Amazing .. I’ll bookmark your blog and take the feeds also…I’m happy to find so many useful info here in the post, we need work out more techniques in this regard, thanks for sharing. capture his heart ebook reviews

The information you have

By ronan1122
The information you have posted is very useful. The sites you have referred was good. Thanks for sharing.. aannemers woningbouw

I have read your article, it

By ronan1122
I have read your article, it is very informative and helpful for me.I admire the valuable information you offer in your articles. Thanks for posting it.. bubblegum casting

Nice post. I learn some

By ronan1122
Nice post. I learn some thing tougher on distinct blogs everyday. Most commonly it is stimulating to learn to read content from other writers and exercise a specific thing there. I’d would rather use some together with the content in my weblog no matter whether you don’t mind. Natually I’ll provide you with a link in your web weblog. Many thanks for sharing. Online Games Offers Homepage

Your article has piqued a

By ronan1122
Your article has piqued a lot of positive interest. I can see why since you have done such a good job of making it interesting. free credit report

Love what you're doing here

By johnmak1122
Love what you're doing here guys, keep it up!.. what does bubblegum casting do

Drumanard estate

By sknifeman
Steve Who did the Transportation Department buy this from? It is a basically an unknown company that owned it, but I would bet some politically connected people own the company. Price went from 2 million to 8 million, plus, from 2000 to 2012. What about the real estate crash??? Tremendous profit made from this by somebody.

Hey There. I found your blog

By zane1122
Hey There. I found your blog using msn. This is a very well written article. I’ll be sure to bookmark it and come back to read more of your useful info. Thanks for the post. I’ll definitely return. Learn More

Nice post. I learn some

By robert1122
Nice post. I learn some thing tougher on distinct blogs everyday. Most commonly it is stimulating to learn to read content from other writers and exercise a specific thing there. I’d would rather use some together with the content in my weblog no matter whether you don’t mind. Natually I’ll provide you with a link in your web weblog. Many thanks for sharing. his response

Lee Cochran, Stream

By alone17
Lee Cochran, Stream Fields’ first professional home and little girl of its creator, blistered the conservancy for favoring a town center link to the exemption of an Eastern End span. aimbot download

estate agents clapham south

By Bradson
estate agents clapham south - The Clapham South and Balham area has a rich history and is constantly buzzing with activity thanks to its close proximity to transport links and entertainment venues.

commercial property agents manchester - We manage over 300 properties including office blocks, industrial estates, retail parades and apartment blocks.

london holiday apartments - London Serviced Apartments offer a range of luxurious apartments. Save up to 30% on comparable hotel costs.

Yacon Root (Capsule) suppliers

By steve7876
I was looking at some of your posts on this website and I conceive this web site is really instructive! Keep putting up..Yacon Root (Capsule) suppliers

Wholesale phytoceramides

By steve7876
He sings this song so beautifully! I have him singing it too, on the Cracker Barrel CD "Josh Turner, Live at the Ryan". Debbie.Wholesale phytoceramides

Is there really no way for

By Hugh
Is there really no way for the project to follow a different route? The home is clearly gorgeous and it may be affected by it. I've seen something similar thanks to La Quinta help, I would never give up on this home if I owned it!

Excellent post

By HilarioSteele
I very likely will not have to clarify everything to my pals. i will be able to merely direct them here. buy social signals adult seo blog posts

Oh Stream Connects Venture

By alone17
Oh Stream Connects Venture enthusiasts view 8664 askance. Tim Hagerty, common advice for the Connects Coalition, e-mailed LEO that people and social, business and work categories absolutely support the two-bridge effort, and that government authorities in The state of kentucky and In “have given us the resources to finance. sensa review

Of particular issue is how

By alone17
Of particular issue is how the physicians within Judaism Hospital’s far-reaching OB/GYN combined, Leading Gynecology and Obstetrics, are addressing these Catholic directives that limit female's libido good care choices. https://plus.google.com/112458942571457568265

Lee Cochran, Stream

By BERENICES
Lee Cochran, Stream Fields’ first professional home and little girl of its creator, blistered the conservancy for favoring a town center link to the exemption of an Eastern End span: “We might not be gazing down the gun barrel of a expensive two-bridge remedy if they had not championed the town center choice so fervently and selfishly decades ago.” click reference link